Peptide labeling by isobaric tags is a powerful approach for the relative quantitative analysis of proteomes in multiple groups. There has been a revolution in the innovation of new isobaric reagents; however, great effort is being made to expand simultaneous labeling groups to identify more labeled peptides and reduce reporter ion signal suppression. We redesigned the original chemical structure of the deuterium isobaric amine-reactive tag developed in our laboratory. We optimized the synthetic pathway to create a new set of 16-plex isobaric tags (IBT-16plex). The novel reagent enabled almost complete labeling of peptides within 90 min, with all labeling reporter ions exhibiting comparable MS/MS signals. Compared to a typical 16plex reagent, TMTpro-16plex, the peptides and proteins identified by IBT-16plex in trypsinized HeLa cells were significantly increased by 14.8 and 8.6%, respectively. Moreover, differences in peptide abundance within 10-fold among multiple groups were barely suppressed in IBT-16plex, whereas the dynamic range in TMTpro-16plex-labeled groups was smaller. After quantitative examination of MCF7 cell proteins, IBT-16plex was confirmed as feasible and useful for evaluating protein responses of glucose-starved MCF7 cells to a glucose-rich medium.